clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Restaurant Experts Name Their Best Meal of 2013

New, 1 comment

As is the tradition at Eater, our closeout of the year is a survey of friends, industry types, and bloggers. We already covered this year's restaurant standbys and top newcomers, tried to sum up the whole year in dining in one word, named the year's hottest dining neighborhood, and remembered 2013's most surprising moments in food. Now, we're talking about the best meals we ate all year. Responses are related in no particular order. Readers, please add your own survey answers in the comments.
Fitler Dining Room was the site of some of the year's most perfect meals. [Photo: FDR/Twitter]

Q: What was the single best meal of 2013?

Danya Henninger, editor of Zagat Philly:

Fitler Dining Room recently held a dinner featuring the ciders of Frecon Farms where every single thing was perfect. Pacing? Perfect. Service? Perfect. Rob Marzinsky's food itself? A warm fruits de mer with a garnish of frozen lime puree was so good I'll never order one of those silly cold seafood platters again, because I know I'll be disappointed. And a plate of pork done five ways was NOT described as "pork five ways"! In addition to that, which made it a great dish to begin with, each of the preparations was spot on, and each tasted different event though they were all from one little heritage piglet. The cider? I'm usually a beer (or cocktails, or after that, wine) girl, but these glasses of apple-y booze turned my head with their nuance and flavors and (not least) the ability to get you buzzed! Even the coffee was fantastic. Go to this restaurant, you won't be disappointed.

Drew Lazor, freelance journalist and columnist for the Philly Daily News:

The other week, when a few friends and I ordered everything on the menu at Little Fish. Chadd Jenkins cooks the best seafood in Philly, but he's also just one of the best chefs around period.

Neal Santos, photographer/occasional blogger/unlikely farmer:

Sitting at the chef's table at Vernick, eating stuff on toast.

Joy Manning, editor of Edible Philly:

In March, I was writing about Christopher Hirshheimer and Melissa Hamilton of The Canal House, and I interviewed them over lunch at their Lambertville NJ studio, where they make their incredible books. They made salad, the most amazing lamb chops, a fruit crisp, and prosecco. There was even a cheese course. Those women are my culinary/publishing heroes.

Michael Klein, editor/producer/columnist/blogger for

Hot chicken and oyster po'boy at the counter at The Fat Ham.

Holly Moore, industry all-rounder behind

Chicken Fricassee at El Varadero, a Cuban Restaurant on Isla Mujeres in Mexico.

Kevin McKenzie of Amusing My Bouche:

For me, the awesome absurdity of the Jason Cichonski and Scott Schroeder collaboration/man-lovefest Whiskey and Waffles Brunch at Ela was a highlight, but I have to say my first meal at Nick Elmi's Laurel. Seeing him cook his own food without constraint of George Perrier or the mighty Restaurant Associates was refreshing and hopefully a glance into more great things to come.

Adam Erace, critic at Philadelphia City Paper and freelance food writer:

I had an unbelievable meal at Fork this year. We went for our one-year wedding anniversary and it was perfect, from the oysters and Champagne to the grapefruit/jasmine soup.

Arthur Etchells, founder of Foobooz:

Pop-up dinner with Justin Bogle and Chris Kearse at Will.

Caroline Russock, food editor at Philadelphia City Paper:

I've got to go with the New York strip tasting at Barclay Prime. Side by side dry aged steak tasting? Incredible.

Kristina Jenkins, editor of Uwishunu:

That's tough. I loved digging in to the phenomenal comfort food at Little Nonna's. The recently launched dinner service at High Street on Market dishes exciting, deliriously delicious fare.

Marcos Espinoza, a.k.a. Fidel Gastro and Top Chef recapper extraordinaire:

Fitler Dining Room. The food and the service kept one-upping each other throughout the whole meal.


2001 Ed Bluestein Boulevard, , TX 78721 (737) 529-8441 Visit Website

The Fat Ham

3131 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19104 215-735-1913 Visit Website

Fitler Dining Room

2201 Spruce Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103 215-732-3331

Little Nonna's

1234 Locust Street, , PA 19107 (215) 546-2100 Visit Website

High Street on Market

308 Market Street, , PA 19106 (215) 625-0988 Visit Website


306 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19106