clock menu more-arrow no yes
Seems like almost everyone agrees that the bar at Avance is a must-hit burger destination.
Seems like almost everyone agrees that the bar at Avance is a must-hit burger destination.
Photo: Eater Philly

9 New Burgers Eater Readers Love

View as Map
Seems like almost everyone agrees that the bar at Avance is a must-hit burger destination.
| Photo: Eater Philly

12355134111232008_10_hasmaps%20%283%29%20%281%29%20%281%29.jpgLast week, we asked Eater Philly readers to share the best new burgers they've found around town over the past year or so. Now, with responses culled from the comments, social media, and the tipline (shunning any uncorroborated shill-y responses, of course) and conveniently mapped, we present to you the nine burgers you need to run out and try right now.

With no limitations imposed except that the burgers be reasonably new, beef burgers still predictably reigned supreme. One vegetarian patty made the cut, and lamb is clearly the current non-beef meat of choice, with multiple ovine entries on the list. In a surprising (though very welcome) Southern twist, the roster also features two pimento cheese burgers.

Check out the map below to see who made the cut — and as always, if you don't see your favorite, sound off in the comments or via the tipline.


Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. Avance

Copy Link
1523 Walnut Street
Philadelphia, PA 19102
While the forward-looking fare being served in the dining room at Avance racks up the accolades, the lamb burger available only at the downstairs bar is capturing a hefty share of the buzz. It's made with Border Springs lamb, feta, onion marmalade, and a brioche bun that even the anti-brioche-bun contingent has gotten behind, and comes with a side of chickpea fries. (Of course, not everyone thinks it quite lives up to the hype.)

2. Border Springs Lamb Farm

Copy Link
51 North 12th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19107
Border Springs lamb also features in the burger at the bar at Avance, but you can try this one out in a much more casual setting. The man behind the menu is Nick Macri, formerly of Southwark, who knows his meat - he's one of the city's most skilled charcutiers and took home 2013 Hop Chef gold with a meat salad.

3. BurgerFi

Copy Link
44 N 12th St
Philadelphia, PA 19107
(267) 928-3882
Visit Website
BurgerFi is a convention center-adjacent, fast-casual chain that seems to roll all the other chains' signatures and gimmicks into one. (Officially published 'secret menu'? Check. Concretes? Check. Ubiquitous bun-brand? You betcha.) But the fact remains, the early word on these burgers has been strongly positive. No specific burger gets the nod here; options run classic and you can tweak the build to your heart's content.

4. The Gaslight

Copy Link
120 Market St
Philadelphia, PA 19106
(215) 925-7691
Visit Website
Jason Cichonski and James Fujioka's menu at this newly revamped Old City bar features a beef burger and a veggie burger with the same set-up (aged cheddar, creamy-spicy sauce, smoked pickles). And it's the veggie burger — built on a smoked paprika-spiked farro and quinoa patty — that got the specific nod from the Eater audience.

5. REX 1516

Copy Link
1516 South St
Philadelphia, PA 19146
(215) 735-1116
Visit Website
The awesome house burger at Rex 1516 has pimento cheese, bacon, crispy fried red onions and bibb lettuce. Even more awesome: on Monday nights, you can opt for the 'burger citywide' and nab the burger with a pint and a shot for just $15. (On Tuesdays and Wednesdays, the same deal applies but with a special burger that changes weekly and has included variations like a poutine burger and a general tso's pork belly burger - follow chef Justin Swain on twitter for food porny updates.)

6. Tap Room on 19th

Copy Link
2400 S 19th St
Philadelphia, PA 19145
(267) 687-7817
Visit Website
Chef Jennifer Choplin makes her patties with a custom LaFrieda blend and offers plenty of decadent options for topping, including a variety of cheeses, bacon, eggs, and — this hits us where it hurts — pork roll. (We've also heard great things about their lamb burger, which would make three lamb entries here, for anyone keeping score at home.)

7. The Fat Ham

Copy Link
3131 Walnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19104
(215) 735-1913
Visit Website
Kevin Sbraga's tiny new Southern spot recently launched lunch, and the pared-down menu has one lunch-only special: the pimento cheese burger. It's served about as simply as it gets, though you can add bacon if you so choose, with a side of sweet potato chips on the side.

8. The Avenue Delicatessen

Copy Link
27 N Lansdowne Ave
Lansdowne, PA 19050
(610) 622-3354
Visit Website
The Americana burger comes about as classic as you'd expect from the name: LTO, bread and butter pickles, and Russian dressing, all perched on a LaFrieda patty. (Though with optional toppings like smoked mozzarella and pancetta, you're welcome to take your burger in another direction entirely.) While Craig LaBan knocked them down a peg for the "big and squishy" bun, the general consensus is that this burger is worth your time (and the fries are definitely no joke).

9. Blackfish

Copy Link
119 Fayette St
Conshohocken, PA 19428
(610) 397-0888
Visit Website
"I don't know if this qualifies as new," writes one reader, "but after a several-year absence Blackfish in Conshy has brought back lunch service and it features their 'Big 'Burb' burger, which is excellent." We'll allow it, especially for a burger topped with the over-the-top classic combo of blue cheese, fried onions, and bacon.

1. Avance

1523 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, PA 19102
While the forward-looking fare being served in the dining room at Avance racks up the accolades, the lamb burger available only at the downstairs bar is capturing a hefty share of the buzz. It's made with Border Springs lamb, feta, onion marmalade, and a brioche bun that even the anti-brioche-bun contingent has gotten behind, and comes with a side of chickpea fries. (Of course, not everyone thinks it quite lives up to the hype.)
1523 Walnut Street
Philadelphia, PA 19102

2. Border Springs Lamb Farm

51 North 12th Street, Philadelphia, PA 19107
Border Springs lamb also features in the burger at the bar at Avance, but you can try this one out in a much more casual setting. The man behind the menu is Nick Macri, formerly of Southwark, who knows his meat - he's one of the city's most skilled charcutiers and took home 2013 Hop Chef gold with a meat salad.
51 North 12th Street
Philadelphia, PA 19107

3. BurgerFi

44 N 12th St, Philadelphia, PA 19107
BurgerFi is a convention center-adjacent, fast-casual chain that seems to roll all the other chains' signatures and gimmicks into one. (Officially published 'secret menu'? Check. Concretes? Check. Ubiquitous bun-brand? You betcha.) But the fact remains, the early word on these burgers has been strongly positive. No specific burger gets the nod here; options run classic and you can tweak the build to your heart's content.
44 N 12th St
Philadelphia, PA 19107

4. The Gaslight

120 Market St, Philadelphia, PA 19106
Jason Cichonski and James Fujioka's menu at this newly revamped Old City bar features a beef burger and a veggie burger with the same set-up (aged cheddar, creamy-spicy sauce, smoked pickles). And it's the veggie burger — built on a smoked paprika-spiked farro and quinoa patty — that got the specific nod from the Eater audience.
120 Market St
Philadelphia, PA 19106

5. REX 1516

1516 South St, Philadelphia, PA 19146
The awesome house burger at Rex 1516 has pimento cheese, bacon, crispy fried red onions and bibb lettuce. Even more awesome: on Monday nights, you can opt for the 'burger citywide' and nab the burger with a pint and a shot for just $15. (On Tuesdays and Wednesdays, the same deal applies but with a special burger that changes weekly and has included variations like a poutine burger and a general tso's pork belly burger - follow chef Justin Swain on twitter for food porny updates.)
1516 South St
Philadelphia, PA 19146

6. Tap Room on 19th

2400 S 19th St, Philadelphia, PA 19145
Chef Jennifer Choplin makes her patties with a custom LaFrieda blend and offers plenty of decadent options for topping, including a variety of cheeses, bacon, eggs, and — this hits us where it hurts — pork roll. (We've also heard great things about their lamb burger, which would make three lamb entries here, for anyone keeping score at home.)
2400 S 19th St
Philadelphia, PA 19145

7. The Fat Ham

3131 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19104
Kevin Sbraga's tiny new Southern spot recently launched lunch, and the pared-down menu has one lunch-only special: the pimento cheese burger. It's served about as simply as it gets, though you can add bacon if you so choose, with a side of sweet potato chips on the side.
3131 Walnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19104

8. The Avenue Delicatessen

27 N Lansdowne Ave, Lansdowne, PA 19050
The Americana burger comes about as classic as you'd expect from the name: LTO, bread and butter pickles, and Russian dressing, all perched on a LaFrieda patty. (Though with optional toppings like smoked mozzarella and pancetta, you're welcome to take your burger in another direction entirely.) While Craig LaBan knocked them down a peg for the "big and squishy" bun, the general consensus is that this burger is worth your time (and the fries are definitely no joke).
27 N Lansdowne Ave
Lansdowne, PA 19050

9. Blackfish

119 Fayette St, Conshohocken, PA 19428
"I don't know if this qualifies as new," writes one reader, "but after a several-year absence Blackfish in Conshy has brought back lunch service and it features their 'Big 'Burb' burger, which is excellent." We'll allow it, especially for a burger topped with the over-the-top classic combo of blue cheese, fried onions, and bacon.
119 Fayette St
Conshohocken, PA 19428

Related Maps